In yesterday’s paper there was an article about a sixteen years old girl, whose both parents died and who’s now working so that she could keep her high school studies, may be forced to quit school as ‘she is making too much money working’ (150 week) and is not entitled to income support any more. She was then advised to get pregnant so that she’d be entitled to the income support.
Now I am not sure that the story is correct, because we all know the media love affairs with the sensational, even if untrue. Yet, true or not, it still raises two important questions:
First, do we want to encourage people to work? Because if we do, this is not the way to go about it. If, for instance, we (whoever we is in this case) decide that 70 a week is the income support rate, then to encourage people to get off it, work must make them better rather than worse off.
For instance, if you work earns you 50 a week, the government would pay you only a decreased amount, say 60. This will make your work worthwhile: you are now working, and your income is increase to 110 rather than 70, this is a sum working for; it costs the tax payer only 60 instead of the original 70. And once you start working, there is a chance that eventually you’ll earn enough not to need the dole at all. The exact details of the scheme can be worked out, but by doing it smart, everyone will win, if this is really what we want.
Second, is the question of law. What happens if the government has raised the school leaving age to 18, as it hopes to do? That means that the girl, forced out of school, is now breaking the law. Will she be taken to custody? Will she be given hefty fines to pay?
I am well familiar with the situation of being forced criminal, because I have been there myself not so long ago. We moved to a new town outside London, just before the beginning of the school year and we needed to find schools for our children. For two we had no problem, but there was no place for the third.
We went to the council and they told us to speak directly to the schools. The schools, on the other hand, told us that as their quota had changed it would be illegal for them to admit my daughter. So we went to back the council, which was kind enough to highlight to us that we were breaking the law, and that our daughter had to go to school. This went on for weeks, fortunately, a vacancy became available in one of the schools and the problem was resolved. But for over a month, we were the law breaking dangerous to the public criminals.
To quote the old king in the Little Prince:
were I to command a general to change into a sea-bird, and were this general not to obey, it would not be the general’s fault. It would be my fault.
But he was a smart king.













